If it feels like pumpkin spice season creeps up earlier every year, you're not imagining it. In 2024, the seasonal peak for orders containing pumpkin spice items occurred on September 17, a full 10 days earlier than in 2023. But this early surge came with a faster cooldown, with demand taking a dip by the end of the month. There's also a reliable second spike in late November, likely driven by Thanksgiving's fondness for all things squash and spice.

Pumpkin Spice is a clear seasonal favorite, and it's also evident that people are looking for new ways to incorporate this flavor into their meals and homes. From starting your day with a dose of protein in Greek and Icelandic Yogurt, to filling your home with the scent of pumpkin spice, this trend shows there is no one way to enjoy it.

Drumroll, please…West Virginia tops the pumpkin spice leaderboard, ordering 91% more pumpkin spice products than the national average. Pennsylvania (+56%) and Oklahoma (+52%) round out the top three. On the flip side, Hawai'i takes the title for the least pumpkin-spicy state, ordering 63% less than average.

See how Georgia compares nationwide
- Relative difference: -7%
- State rank: 33

Top ranked states
1. West Virginia
2. Pennsylvania
3. Oklahoma
4. Ohio
5. Delaware

Lowest ranked states
1. Hawaii
2. Louisiana
3. District of Columbia
4. California
5. Alaska