Cities with the most expensive homes in the Columbus, Indiana metro area Stacker Columbus, IN News Stacker - Typical home value: $203,563- 1-year price change: +5.8%- 5-year price change: +63.3% #5. Taylorsville, IN No Automated Backlink Off Stacker - Typical home value: $248,386- 1-year price change: +3.4%- 5-year price change: +60.5% #4. Hope, IN No Automated Backlink Off Stacker - Typical home value: $274,033- 1-year price change: +5.2%- 5-year price change: +52.6% #3. Hartsville, IN No Automated Backlink Off Stacker - Typical home value: $278,678- 1-year price change: +2.9%- 5-year price change: +43.4% #2. Columbus, IN No Automated Backlink Off Stacker - Typical home value: $279,007- 1-year price change: +4.2%- 5-year price change: +49.7% #1. Elizabethtown, IN Movies and TV shows casting in Columbus, Indiana No Automated Backlink Off Volodymyr Kyrylyuk // Shutterstock