Cities with the most expensive homes in the Columbus, Indiana metro area Stacker Columbus, IN News Stacker - Typical home value: $190,133- 1-year price change: +4.9%- 5-year price change: +57.2% #5. Taylorsville, IN No Automated Backlink Off Stacker - Typical home value: $240,432- 1-year price change: +3.0%- 5-year price change: +57.0% #4. Hope, IN No Automated Backlink Off Stacker - Typical home value: $267,404- 1-year price change: +6.0%- 5-year price change: +50.1% #3. Hartsville, IN No Automated Backlink Off Stacker - Typical home value: $271,833- 1-year price change: +3.1%- 5-year price change: +41.8% #2. Columbus, IN No Automated Backlink Off Stacker - Typical home value: $275,377- 1-year price change: +4.6%- 5-year price change: +48.1% #1. Elizabethtown, IN Cheapest gas stations in Columbus, Indiana No Automated Backlink Off FOTOGRIN // Shutterstock