Where people in Ithaca are looking to buy homes Stacker #10. Seneca Falls, NY - View share: 2.4%- Median listing price: $309,900- Median listing price per square foot: $154 #9. Utica, NY - View share: 2.4%- Median listing price: $249,900- Median listing price per square foot: $158 #8. New York, NY - View share: 2.9%- Median listing price: $759,500- Median listing price per square foot: $506 #7. Albany, NY - View share: 3.8%- Median listing price: $436,950- Median listing price per square foot: $245 #6. Auburn, NY - View share: 4.0%- Median listing price: $329,450- Median listing price per square foot: $169 Highest-rated cafes in the Ithaca area by diners #5. Elmira, NY - View share: 4.2%- Median listing price: $172,175- Median listing price per square foot: $103 #4. Rochester, NY - View share: 5.9%- Median listing price: $277,500- Median listing price per square foot: $168 #3. Cortland, NY - View share: 7.7%- Median listing price: $189,725- Median listing price per square foot: $132 #2. Binghamton, NY - View share: 7.8%- Median listing price: $217,450- Median listing price per square foot: $122 #1. Syracuse, NY - View share: 8.6%- Median listing price: $293,248- Median listing price per square foot: $176 Highest-paying jobs in Ithaca shisu_ka // Shutterstock