People from these metros are looking to buy homes in Columbus, Indiana Stacker #10. Evansville, IN - View share: 1.4% #9. Atlanta, GA - View share: 1.8% #8. Terre Haute, IN - View share: 1.9% #7. Louisville, KY - View share: 3.7% #6. Seymour, IN - View share: 4.3% Cities with the most expensive homes in the Columbus, Indiana metro area #5. Bloomington, IN - View share: 4.6% #4. Washington, DC - View share: 6.6% #3. Chicago, IL - View share: 6.6% #2. New York, NY - View share: 7.0% #1. Indianapolis, IN - View share: 30.0% How much house does $500,000 buy you in Columbus, Indiana? shisu_ka // Shutterstock